Forum

Thank you very much dear shooting sir!
I mistook one thing ie the base date is 2015/11 but I wrote 2011/11....
Ive shown honesty in my analysis .......Thank you very much again!

Another good analysis, good job saugat /mb ji
i hope people will understand your effort to share information for good purchase .
i think pic can improve the all fundamental and can be good company but to be as strong as Shikhar,they have to do miracle or shikhar have to do bad . My point is ,there is big gap between those company and shikhar is already in different level .

I see players are really creating artificial demand in PIC.Big players are placing big numbers of buying orders themselves!See in ngbbl case,there are high volume transection,but here......no just 10 kitta ...this way....
Yesterday big players made a big transaction of 2000 kitta.
Lets break this fraud chain!

SICL vs PIC

Price increased within short period
PIC was 433 on 2011/11/29 but SICL was 800 on the same day!
PIC was 1452 on yesterday but SICL was 1760 on the same day.
PIC increased by 235%
Sicl increased by 149%
[Increment calculation for sicl as follows due to its 24% bonus adjustment!(132+17)
[((1856-800)/800)100+((1760-1496)/1496)100]]
Based on the price rise SICL has to increase a lot ie 86% more than pic.
Decision:SICL.

EPS annualised :
PIC: 28
SICL:39(based on adjusted paid up after 24% bonus)
Decision:SICL

P/E based on annualised eps
PIC:51.85
SICL:45.12
Decision: SICL

Netwoth
PIC:209 (Its networth could be improved after FPO but could effect badly due to huge claim,reserve can be used to pay claim)
SICL:301
Decision:SICL

Premium collection:Claim to pay ratio
PIC: 1:4 (39:166)
SICL:1:1-(75:69)
Decision:SICL

Issued Insurance Policies
PIC:40790
SICL:90381
Decision :SICL

Renewal of policies(faith)
PIC:4314
SICL:11681
Decision:SICL

Premium Collection
PIC:39 karod
SICL:75 karod
Decision: SICL

Net profit
pic:4 karod
sicl:10 karod
Decision: sicl

Emergency Fund
pic:0
sicl:1 karod
Decision: sicl

Reserve
pic:20 karod
sicl:46 karod
Decision:sicl

Paid up
PIC:29 karod [after 30% bonus 37.7 karod,after FPO 44 karod )
SICL:50.67 karod
Decision PIC.

Bonus Declared
PIC:30%(its not clear that bonus is for FPO or not,if given it will less than sicl)
SICL:24%
Decision PIC

Note: based on Q2 report,data are rounded off.Please correct me where I mistook!Please make your wise comments!
Since every aspects show that shikhar is worthy enough why not to decide shikhar.But looking market depth and trading size ,PIC is a big deal of big players.